This lesson
offers an introduction to 'thiranayvu'- ie literary criticism
and discusses the various types of criticism. Literary criticism
is an attempt to examine and analyze the various aspects of a
literary text. There are several types of literary criticism.
Of these 8 are considered to be the fundamental types of criticism.
They are: 'paarattumurai thiranayvu' ie (appreciative criticism),
'mudivumurai thiranayvu' ie (judicial criticism), 'vithimurai
thiranayvu' ie (prescriptive criticism), 'seluthunilai thiranayvu'
or 'padaippuvazhi thiranayvu' (inductive criticism), 'vilakkamurai
thiranayvu' ie (rephrasing), 'mathipeetumurai thiranayvu' ie (evaluation),
'oppeetu thiranayvu' ie (comparative criticism) and 'paguppumurai
thiranayvu' ie (analytical criticism). This lesson examines the
first 4 types of criticism. It defines each of these 4 types of
criticism and discusses their merits and limitations.
Appreciative
criticism or 'Parattumurai thiranayvu' is the method of examining
the merits of a literary work. This type of criticism celebrates
a literary text by focusing only on its strengths. It is, therefore,
constructive by nature. However, this type of criticism is not
holistic. It does not explore all the aspects of a literary text.
Judicial
Criticism or 'Mudivumurai thiranayvu' draws conclusions about
a literary text on the basis of certain established conventions
or parameters. This type of criticism is very narrow in its approach.
In this type of criticism there is always the danger of ignoring
the uniqueness of a text or its individual merits, simply because
they don't fit in to the predetermined set of parameters.
Prescriptive
criticism or 'vithimurai thiranayvu' is almost similar to judicial
criticism. While judicial criticism tries to find out whether
a text follows and fulfills certain parameters, prescriptive criticism
applies a set of predetermined theories to a text irrespective
of their validity and interprets the text in the light of these
theories. This type of criticism is again unreliable as it sets
the theory above the text.
Inductive
criticism or 'seluthunilai thiranayvu' draws its theories from
a literary text. It rejects the methods propounded by judicial
and prescriptive criticisms. It asserts the uniqueness of a literary
text and emphasizes the idea that a literary text cannot be judged
or evaluated on the basis of certain external parameters or theories
alone. It also rejects the view that a text can be studied in
comparison with other texts.