studies
entirely on Sanskrit which represents the posterior end of the ancient
Indo-European line of speech in contradistinction to Tamil which represents
its anterior end have met with a blind alley and arrived at several unscientific
and illogical conclusion, in their extreme frustration and despair. The
Israelites, though they wandered in the wilderness for forty years, at
last found out the right path. But the western linguists who are wandering
in the wilderness of Sanskrit, will never be able to find out the right
path even after forty aeons. This is a blessing in disguise to the obscurantists,
to whom historical treatment of languages leading to enlightenment of
humanity is a bete noire and bugbear. This was why Descriptive Linguistics
was readily accepted by the Sanskritists with great enthusiasm, and is
being diligently propagated throughout India.
The historical treatment of words and languages,
as conceived by the expounders of Descriptive Linguistics, consists in
taking the order in which words and their meanings occur in the existing
literature, for their original one. This may be true in the case of a
new or recent language, but not in that of an old language like Tamil,
whose ancient literature has become extinct and in whose extant literature
words and meanings occur according to the requirements of the context,
and not in the order of their formation or origination. For instance,
the word pai. which has about twenty
meanings, occurs in Tolkppiyam, the oldest
lierary work extant in Tamil only in its latest sense, viz., place.
As all the pre-Tolkppiyam works have gone
into oblivion, it is impossible for us to find out the original order
in which words and their meanings have come into existence. The only order
in which we can arrange them at present; so as to approximate to the original
one, is the logical order.
Total loss of morphemes is an inevitable
feature of linguistic change. There is evidence that this loss proceeds
at about the same average rate for all languages. A number of calculations
have indicated that this rate is about 19 percent per thousand years for
the most basic vocabulary. Suppose two languages separate completely so
that their subsequent histories are independent, and
|